NLEN

How do you tell a good fish oil?

Check four things: how much EPA and DHA a daily dose contains, in which form, how fresh the oil is (the TOTOX value), and whether the maker can show it with an analysis per batch. Of 72 omega-3 supplements tested, nearly 4 in 10 were over the recommended oxidation limit, and 2 in 3 of the flavoured ones.

By Jeroen, Daily Impact ·

What a test of 72 supplements found

Researchers at George Washington University analysed 72 omega-3 supplements sold in the United States between 2014 and 2020. 28 of them, nearly 4 in 10, were above the limit for TOTOX, the total oxidation score. Flavour made the biggest difference: 68% of the flavoured products were over the limit, against 13% of the unflavoured ones.

Oxidised oil has lost part of its omega-3, and the label does not show it. That is why you look further than the front of the box.

Share of 72 omega-3 supplements above the recommended limit

TOTOX, flavoured
68%
TOTOX, unflavoured
13%
Peroxide value, flavoured
65%
Peroxide value, unflavoured
32%
Source: Hands et al., Journal of Dietary Supplements, 2024, United States
Show the numbers
TOTOX, flavoured68%
TOTOX, unflavoured13%
Peroxide value, flavoured65%
Peroxide value, unflavoured32%

1. Count EPA and DHA per daily dose

"1,000 mg fish oil" says how much oil is in a capsule. What counts is how much EPA and DHA is in it, per daily dose. The EU links 250 mg EPA and DHA a day to the normal working of the heart. Check the label: per capsule or per spoon, times the number a day.

2. Check the form

In fish, omega-3 sits in triglycerides. Many concentrates are processed into ethyl esters. In a comparison in healthy adults, about 27% less EPA and DHA was absorbed from ethyl esters than from natural fish oil. Re-esterified triglycerides, ethyl esters turned back into triglycerides, scored 24% higher than natural oil.

Uptake of EPA and DHA by form, natural fish oil = 100

Ethyl esters
73
Natural fish oil
100
Re-esterified triglycerides
124
Source: Dyerberg et al., 2010
Show the numbers
Ethyl esters73
Natural fish oil100
Re-esterified triglycerides124

The form is often missing from the label. Then ask the maker: natural triglycerides, ethyl esters or re-esterified?

3. Ask for the TOTOX value

GOED, the omega-3 industry association, sets three limits: a peroxide value of at most 5, an anisidine value of at most 20, and a TOTOX of at most 26. TOTOX is twice the peroxide value plus the anisidine value. The lower, the fresher.

One catch: in oil with added flavour, the anisidine test is unreliable, GOED notes itself. A lemon flavour also masks the smell by which you would notice rancid oil yourself. With a flavoured oil, ask for the values of the oil before the flavour went in.

4. Origin and an analysis per batch

Fishing boats and fishermen's huts on the beach below a white coastal village
Fishing boats on the beach of a Portuguese coastal village, December 2025.

A good maker can tell you where and when the fish was caught, and shows an analysis per batch: oxidation, EPA and DHA content, and heavy metals, PCBs and dioxins. Is there no batch number, or no answer to your question? That says something too.

“EPA and DHA are mostly in oily fish. Look at how often it is on your plate, and how sure you are of how fresh that fish is and where it comes from.”

Jeroen, Daily Impact

What these numbers do not tell you

  • The test covered 72 products sold in the United States between 2014 and 2020. It says nothing about any specific brand on the Belgian market.
  • The GOED limits are a voluntary industry standard. Nobody checks them on every jar.
  • A good analysis says how the oil left the factory. After opening, store it cool and closed.

Questions people ask

What is a good TOTOX value for fish oil?

26 or lower is the limit in the GOED standard. The lower the number, the fresher the oil. In flavoured oil, the value is less reliable.

Is liquid fish oil better than capsules?

None of these studies compared the two. What counts is dose, form and freshness. With liquid oil you reach a high dose with one spoon; with capsules you often need several for the same amount.

Can I take fish oil with blood thinners?

Talk to your doctor first, especially at higher doses. In a free call, a therapist also looks at the medication you take.

Read next