NLEN

Is your sleep score accurate?

Partly. In a sleep lab test of seven consumer trackers, every device recognised sleep well, but most missed a large share of the minutes people lay awake, and the sleep stages they reported did not match the lab.

By Jeroen, Daily Impact ·

Seven trackers against the lab

At the Naval Health Research Center, 34 healthy young adults slept three nights in a lab wired to polysomnography, the gold standard, while wearing or using seven consumer trackers. Four sat on the wrist, three next to the bed.

  • Sleep: every device caught at least 93% of the minutes people were asleep.
  • Awake: the devices recognised only 18% to 54% of the minutes people were awake.
  • Sleep stages: the results were mixed, and the devices tended to do worse on the night with disrupted sleep.

The score can change your day

At Colorado College, 164 students were told a sleep reading of their brain waves showed either 28.7% or 16.2% REM sleep. The reading was made up. Students told they had slept above average scored better on two tests of attention and processing, whatever they themselves said about their night.

“Putting a number on your sleep is fine, but review it once a week, and track it for a few weeks, not forever. Then again after five months, to see the difference.”

Jeroen, Daily Impact

How to read it

  • Look at the week. One night says little, a trend over weeks says more.
  • Trust total sleep more than the split into deep, light and REM.
  • Track for a few weeks when you change something, then put it away and check again months later.

The limits

  • The lab study tested models from around 2019. Newer devices may do better, or worse.
  • Both studies used healthy young people.

Questions people ask

Should you check your sleep score every morning?

Jeroen reviews it once a week. In the Colorado study, simply being told you slept badly went with worse test scores, so a daily verdict can cost you more than it tells you.

What does a sleep tracker measure best?

Whether you are asleep. That part held up in the lab for all seven devices. Time awake and sleep stages were far less reliable.

Read next