NLEN

Should you eat vegetables with fat?

Yes. When seven adults ate a salad with a fat-free dressing, almost none of the carotenoids from the carrots, tomatoes and spinach showed up in their blood, and every step up in fat let more of them through.

By Jeroen, Daily Impact ·

Same salad, three dressings

At Iowa State University, seven adults each ate the same salad three times: spinach, romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes and carrots. Only the dressing changed. It held 0, 6 or 28 grams of canola oil, with at least two weeks between visits.

The researchers took blood every hour for twelve hours. After the fat-free version, the amount of alpha-carotene, beta-carotene and lycopene they found was negligible. With 6 grams it rose, and with 28 grams it rose again.

Why the fat decides

Carotenoids dissolve in fat and barely in water. Your gut packs them, together with the fat from the meal, into small particles that carry them into the blood. The Iowa team measured exactly those particles. No fat on the plate, almost nothing to carry them.

Butter, canola or soybean oil?

A larger study at Purdue University gave 29 healthy adults identical salads with 3, 8 or 20 grams of canola oil, soybean oil or butter. Across all three fats, 20 grams led to more absorption than 3 or 8 grams. The kind of fat mattered less than the amount. Canola leaned slightly ahead of butter for two carotenoids, by a margin small enough to be chance.

“Everyone avoids saturated fats, and that is the clearest sign that we do not know what is really healthy, or even necessary. Fats that people see as healthy can be unhealthy too. The misunderstandings are more common than the truth, and that is where the real impact on your health is hidden.”

Jeroen, Daily Impact

In the Purdue salads, butter did its job. The plates that lost out were the ones with the least fat.

What this looks like on a plate

  • Steamed vegetables: finish them with a knob of butter or a spoon of oil.
  • Salad: skip the fat-free dressing. In the Iowa study it let almost nothing through.
  • Raw carrots or tomatoes as a snack: eat them with something that has fat in it, like cheese, nuts or hummus.

None of this needs a new diet. Jeroen's rule for most habits is "the basics, done well, 80% of the time", and this one is about as basic as it gets.

What these studies do not tell you

  • They are small: 7 and 29 people, each measured after a single meal.
  • They measured how much reached the blood. What that does for your health over months or years was outside the study.
  • Olive oil was not tested in either study.

Read next